I have been practicing architecture for over 15 years with a concentration on healthcare projects. For those that are familiar with medical planning, you know that there is a certain rigor that comes with laying out the functions of a hospital. Many times, the majority of our time and effort within the design phase is drawing and redrawing the 2-dimesional plans to get them to respond to the operations of the hospital – unfortunately, sometimes at the detriment of the architectural design. To me, competent medical planning is only half of the solution. As architects, we must also be inspired to create spaces that enhance the patient, family and staff experience without sacrificing the function of the building.
Don’t get me wrong, efficient medical planning is very important to the composition of a design. Well-organized planning can help save operational costs and provide the backbone for the appropriate functions of a medical facility. Unfortunately, frequently, the 2-dimensional medical plan becomes the absolute basis for the architectural form and resolution of the building. We often call this an “extruded plan” solution. While this type of solution effectively addresses the functions of a hospital it commonly lacks exploration and refined resolution of the 3-dimesional spaces and form culminating in uninspired experiences for the patient, family and staff.
So, how do we find the balance? Here are some suggestions:
- Stop thinking about medical planning and architectural design as separate responsibilities. These tasks should be integrated early in the project and therefore there should be dialogue about these aspects from the very beginning. Consider more cross training and cross pollination of staff.
- Encourage designers and those that tend to be responsible of the aesthetic design of the building to gain a better understanding of medical planning. Designers should have a keen interest in the function of the interior spaces and need to take initiative to learn basic aspects of medical planning.
- Encourage those individuals who are typically responsible for medical planning to think more in 3-dimensions. Engage dialogue about the architectural design early in the planning process and explore options that address shape, form and space – beyond the 2-dimesional planning.
- Promote a culture of project delivery and design process that values the amalgamation of medical planning and architectural design as mutually important. This may come in the form of a process that allows designers and planners to work more collaboratively very early in the planning process.
What are your thoughts?
Follow Jason on Twitter @jasonschroer




The fastest growing population in America is the elderly and while long term care has vastly improved over the past decades, much can still be done to develop a more appropriate environment that promotes healthy, successful aging. Successful aging is defined as the avoidance of disease and disability, maintenance of high physical and cognitive function, and continued engagement in social and productive activities. The image many Americans see when asked about getting older is not typically a favorable one and ranges from an array of physical disabilities to the burden one may put on family members. Our job as designers, architects, and planners should be to provide an environment that will fulfill the needs and desires of the older population using evidence based design. The social and physical environments of long term care play a significant part in the well-being of a resident by helping establish a sense of community vs. institutionalism and isolation.
Around here we often think of where architecture meets healthcare, simply because that’s what we do, we design healthcare facilities. But, what about a similar intersection of fields, where art meets medicine in the field of medical illustration. Personally, I find it fascinating. I was reminded of my fascination while flipping through HealthLeaders Magazine. The Personalities section highlighted Gary Lees, the director of the Johns Hopkins School of Medicine’s Department of Art as Applied to Medicine.
It was almost too obvious. Sitting among thousands of fellow designers, planners and innovators in the healthcare design field.